A consultant is not mandatory for any ISO certification, and your certification body may not help you. Can you do it yourself, then, or does a consultant pay for themselves? After reading this article you will know which routes there are, what a consultant takes over, where your own time goes, when help pays off, why your certification body may not help you and how to choose a consultant.
Doing it yourself, guidance or separate help with ISO certification
For every ISO standard you first build a management system. Those are the arrangements on how you work, recorded and in use. After that a certification body assesses it in an audit. For building it you have three routes:
- Doing it yourself. Someone in your company reads the standard, makes the arrangements and oversees the process. This costs the least money and the most of your own hours.
- Guidance. A consultant, also called an implementation partner, guides you from the start to the certificate. They explain the requirements, help write and prepare you for the audit.
- Separate help. You build it yourself and hire help for a part, such as a training on the standard, an outsider for the internal audit or software that organises your documents and records.
Tasks of an ISO consultant and what stays with you
A consultant mainly takes over the research and the writing. What the auditor assesses, you do yourself. In a guidance process a consultant usually does the following:
- explaining what the standard asks of your company and what you already have;
- drawing up documents, such as policy, procedures and a risk assessment;
- explaining things to your people and carrying out or preparing the internal audit;
- preparing you for the audit and helping think about resolving nonconformities.
What stays with you is exactly what the auditor looks at. In stage 2 the auditor assesses on site whether you work as agreed. It is also assessed whether you measure your objectives and adjust course. In addition it is checked whether the internal audit and management review have been done. And whether your management takes responsibility for the policy. That is how it is set out in ISO/IEC 17021-1, the standard with requirements for certification bodies. You create the records that prove this. Your people answer the auditor's questions. The certification body decides on the certificate. Someone other than the auditor does that. That is why no consultant can promise you a certificate.
Your own time in an ISO process
How many hours a process costs you depends on your company, your standard and your starting point. CertificeerWijzer does not yet have a reliable figure for this. What is clear is where the time goes. It is also clear which part a consultant can take over:
| Component | What you do | With a consultant |
|---|---|---|
| Building | researching what the standard asks, making arrangements and writing them down | largely transferable; the choices and the explanation of how you work stay with you |
| Running | working as agreed and recording what happens | stays with you |
| Internal audit and management review | checking your system and discussing it with management | an outsider can do the internal audit; the management review stays with you |
| Audit | receiving the auditor, showing them around and showing your records | stays with you |
| Nonconformities | finding the cause and resolving it | help with the approach; you do the resolving |
The audit itself is the smallest part. For ISO 9001 stage 1 and stage 2 together take 1.5 days for a company with 1 to 5 FTE. Global ACI-TECH-3-004 (IAF MD 5) prescribes this. A consultant mainly shortens the building stage. For ISO 9001, starting from scratch, you can count on about eight months. For at least three months of that your system is running. Three to four months of that is waiting time at the certification body. Those two do not get shorter with a consultant. So request quotes straight away, even with a consultant. Then the waiting time runs while you build. The steps for ISO 9001 show how that fits together.
When an ISO consultant pays off and when not
A consultant pays off if their own hours replace yours. That happens at a point where you yourself are slow or uncertain. This mainly applies in three situations:
- No knowledge in house. Nobody in your company has worked with an ISO standard before. A consultant knows what an auditor wants to see. That way you do not write documents nobody asks for. And you do not miss anything that is required.
- Little time. The people who have to do it have their diaries full of client work. Then the process slips every month. A consultant with fixed appointments keeps up the pace.
- A fixed deadline. A customer or tender requires the certificate by a date. A major nonconformity in stage 2 must be resolved before you get the certificate. If that does not succeed within six months, a new stage 2 follows. A consultant who knows the requirements reduces that risk. For ISO 9001 with a deadline you are best off starting ten months in advance.
Doing it yourself is more obvious in three cases. Someone in your company already knows the standard, for example from a previous employer. You already work with fixed arrangements, such as work instructions and a complaints log. Or you add a second standard to a system that is already in place. Many companies then choose a middle way. They build it themselves, with a training beforehand. An outsider does the internal audit. Anyone who wants several standards at once can also combine them in one system.
Advice and impartiality at ISO certification bodies
A certification body may not itself help build the system it certifies. This also applies to every other part of the same legal entity. ISO/IEC 17021-1 requires this. The accreditation body checks it. In the Netherlands that is the Dutch accreditation body. Advice here means: writing manuals or procedures for you. It also applies if you get solutions tailored to your company. General explanation is allowed. Think of what a requirement means, where you can improve, or a training open to everyone. That is allowed as long as it contains no solution for your company.
More difficult is a consultancy that has a link with a certification body, for example through the same owner. ISO/IEC 17021-1 calls advice from such a consultancy a major threat to the impartiality of the certification body. The certification body must then demonstrate that its judgement of you is not at risk. The recognised way is in the text of the standard itself. The certification body certifies your system only two years after the end of the advice. Another measure is also allowed, if it is equally strong. An independent consultant with their own company also counts as a consultancy here. That is why your certification body asks in the application whether you have had advice, and from whom.
Two other rules from the same standard affect your choice:
- Auditor. Someone who has advised you is not deployed by the certification body on your audits for two years after the end of that advice.
- Promises. A certification body may not say or suggest that certification is easier, faster or cheaper with a particular consultancy. If a consultant makes such claims about the certification body, the certification body must correct them.
So choose a consultant who is independent of the certification body you want. Or take those two years into account in your planning.
Choosing an ISO consultant
A good consultant knows your standard and your type of company. They say in advance what they will do themselves and what you have to do. A good consultant also builds a system that you can maintain yourself afterwards. When comparing proposals, pay attention to these points:
- Experience. Ask about processes with the same standard at a company of your size and in your sector.
- Who does the work. Agree who sits at the table with you: the consultant who writes the proposal or a colleague.
- Your hours. Ask per stage how many hours the process requires of you and your people. That way you compare what it costs you in total. That includes the time that is not on the consultant's invoice.
- Price. Ask for a fixed price or a maximum number of days. Also ask what it costs if the audit produces nonconformities.
- Your own system. Have the documents written in your words and in the programs you already use. The auditor assesses whether you work as written. A manual nobody knows therefore does not help you.
- Link with a certification body. Ask whether the consultant is affiliated with a certification body. A promise that it will be easier with one certification body is a reason to ask further. The same applies to a guarantee of the certificate.
Consultancies that offer guidance towards a certificate as a core service are listed under the implementation partners. You choose your certification body separately. Pay attention to who may cover your standard and sector and what it costs over three years. That is explained in choosing a certification body.
At CertificeerWijzer you tell us once where you stand with your management system. Also tell us what you are looking for help with. We select implementation partners that suit your situation. You compare their proposals on price and approach. Certification bodies are not among them, because they may not advise.
Sources
- IAS, summary of ISO/IEC 17021-1:2015 section 5 (impartiality, 5.2.5 up to and including 5.2.10) cdn-v2.iasonline.org
- PJR, ISO/IEC 17021-1 webinar (full text of 5.2.7) pjr.com
- ISO/IEC 17021-1:2015, definition of management system consultancy, via the ERA terminology list era.europa.eu
- European Accreditation, FAQ 33.1 Impartiality (5.2.7) european-accreditation.org
- Department of Standards Malaysia, ACB 6 (text of 17021-1 5.2.9 on claims by consultants) jsm.gov.my
- IAS, summary of ISO/IEC 17021-1:2015 section 9 (application, stage 2, decision) iasonline.org
- Global ACI-TECH-3-004 (M) version 1.0, Determination of Audit Time (was IAF MD 5:2023) sys.global-aci.org