Online you often read that you have 90 days to resolve a nonconformity, but that deadline is not in the standard for certification bodies. What really happens during a certification audit, and what if the auditor finds something? After reading this article you will know which rules every audit follows, what happens in stage 1 and stage 2, how nonconformities and the decision work, which audits follow in the years after, and what you do if you disagree.
Rules for every certification audit
Every accredited certification body works according to ISO/IEC 17021-1, the standard with requirements for certification bodies. In the Netherlands, the Dutch accreditation body checks whether the certification body complies with it. That standard applies to certifying management systems, from ISO 9001 to ISO 14001. What differs per standard, such as the sectors for which a certification body is approved for ISO 9001, is on the standard pages.
You notice three rules before the audit even starts:
- No advice. The certification body may not advise you on the system it assesses. Nor may the auditor suggest a cause or solution for a nonconformity. You get help from a consultant who is independent of the certification body.
- Insight into the calculation. The certification body records how much audit time is needed and why. Under Global ACI-TECH-3-004 (was IAF MD 5) the certification body gives that calculation, with its justification, to you. It is part of the contract.
- Decision by someone else. Your certificate is decided on by someone who did not carry out the audit.
Timeline of an ISO certification
For every standard, the first three-year cycle looks like this:
| Moment | What happens | Who |
|---|---|---|
| Start | you request quotes; the certification body calculates the audit time | you and the certification body |
| Before stage 1 | your system is running; internal audit and management review are planned and under way | you, possibly with a consultant |
| Stage 1 | the auditor checks whether you are ready | auditor |
| Before stage 2 | you resolve bottlenecks and complete the internal audit and management review | you |
| Stage 2 | the auditor tests whether your system works | auditor |
| No later than 6 months after the last day of stage 2 | major nonconformities are resolved, otherwise a new stage 2 follows | you |
| Decision | someone other than the auditor decides; the three years begin | certification body |
| Within 12 months after the decision | first surveillance audit | auditor |
| The calendar year after that | second surveillance audit | auditor |
| Before the expiry date | recertification completed | auditor and certification body |
How to prepare for the audit days themselves is explained in preparing for the audit.
Stage 1 of the certification audit
In stage 1 the auditor examines whether you are ready for the real test. The auditor looks at:
- what the certificate covers: which locations, which processes and which work;
- the description of your system, your policy and your objectives;
- the laws and regulations that apply to you;
- whether your internal audit and your management review are planned and under way. In the management review, management checks whether the system works.
The auditor records what is not yet right. If those points are still open in stage 2, they can become a nonconformity. If too much is still open, the certification body can postpone stage 2. It can also repeat stage 1 in full or in part. How much time there is between the stages depends on what you have to resolve. After stage 1 you hear what the auditor has decided.
Stage 2 of the certification audit
In stage 2 the auditor comes on site to check whether your system works in practice. The auditor walks along on the shop floor and talks to employees. Your technician or district nurse, for example, is asked how they pass on a complaint. If they do not know, no manual will help. The auditor also tests whether you measure and discuss your objectives. Another topic is whether you comply with laws and customer agreements and how you control your processes. Finally, the auditor checks whether your internal audit and management review have been completed and produce results.
Part of the audit can be done remotely, by video. Under Global ACI-TECH-3-003 (was IAF MD 4) the certification body first assesses the risks of that. You agree on it together before it happens. How many days the auditor comes is stated in the quote. How that number is arrived at is explained in the costs of certification.
Major and minor nonconformities in an ISO audit
Whatever does not meet the standard, the auditor records as a nonconformity. The evidence is added to it. The auditor discusses every nonconformity with you. If you disagree, that difference goes into the report. ISO/IEC 17021-1 recognises two types:
- Major nonconformity (major). This is a shortcoming that may prevent your system from achieving its purpose. It can also be a shortcoming that raises serious doubt about whether a process is under control. For example because you never carry out an internal audit. Or because you make trips without the mandatory vehicle check. A series of minor nonconformities on the same point can also together amount to a major one.
- Minor nonconformity (minor). An error that does not prevent your system from achieving its purpose. Think of one outdated work instruction, while the work itself goes well.
An opportunity for improvement or observation in your report is not a nonconformity. It places no obligation on you. It is often wise to act on it, though.
For every nonconformity you look for the cause. Then you fix the error. That is called a correction. You also take a measure so that it does not recur. That is called a corrective action. You do this within a deadline set by the certification body. A major must be demonstrably resolved before you receive the certificate. For a minor an approved plan is enough. If the certification body cannot verify the resolution of a major within 6 months after the last day of stage 2, stage 2 has to be done again. You pay for it again.
Online you often see fixed deadlines, such as "90 days". They are not in ISO/IEC 17021-1. The deadline is in the regulations of your certification body. That is the document with the certification body's own rules. Ask about it before you sign.
Certificate decision after the ISO audit
The auditor gives a recommendation. The decision is taken by someone else within the certification body. That person was not at the audit. They first check whether the report is complete. They also check whether every major has been resolved. They further check whether there is a plan for every minor. Your first three-year period runs from that decision.
Surveillance audits and recertification of an ISO certificate
After the decision the auditor returns at least once per calendar year for a surveillance audit. That does not apply in the year of the recertification. The first surveillance audit falls within 12 months after the decision. The auditor then looks at least at your internal audits and management review. Your complaints are also covered, as is what you have done with earlier nonconformities. The auditor also checks whether you achieve your objectives and what has changed at your organisation. Do you get a major in a surveillance audit? Then your certification body's deadline applies. If you do not resolve it in time, the certification body can suspend your certificate.
You complete the recertification before your certificate expires. What happens if you just miss that, and how your certificate can still be restored within 6 months, is explained in recertification.
The recertification is also a logical moment to compare certification bodies. You can then transfer without starting over.
Suspension and withdrawal of an ISO certificate
A certification body suspends your certificate if you no longer meet the requirements. That also happens if you do not have a surveillance audit or recertification carried out on time. Sometimes you ask for it yourself. During a suspension your certificate is temporarily not valid. ISO/IEC 17021-1 states in a note that a suspension usually lasts no longer than 6 months. The exact term is in the regulations. If you resolve the problem, the certification body restores your certificate. If you do not, it withdraws it. Or it removes the work or the site where things went wrong from your certificate.
After a complaint about your company, after a change at your organisation or after a suspension, the certification body may come at short notice. Coming unannounced is also allowed. The certification body must tell you in advance under which conditions that happens. This is usually in the regulations. Because you cannot then object to who comes, the certification body must take extra care in choosing which auditors go.
Appeal and complaint in a certification audit
If you think a decision or a major is unjustified, you can lodge an appeal with the certification body. If you have a complaint about how the certification body works, you submit a complaint. Under ISO/IEC 17021-1 the following applies to both:
- Different decision-maker. Your appeal or complaint is decided on by someone who was not previously involved.
- Notice and progress. You receive an acknowledgement of receipt. You hear how things stand. You receive the outcome and a formal close of the procedure.
- No disadvantage. Anyone who appeals or complains may not be penalised for it.
If you cannot resolve it with the certification body, you can file a report with the Dutch accreditation body. The Dutch accreditation body supervises the certification body.
Comparing certification bodies for your ISO audit
The rules for the audit are the same at every accredited certification body. The certification bodies themselves do differ. They differ in price, in knowledge of your sector and in their regulations. The regulations determine, for example, the deadline for nonconformities and the conditions for an unannounced audit. How the number of audit days is calculated and what a day costs is explained in the costs of certification.
At CertificeerWijzer you request quotes with a single request. They go to certification bodies that may certify your standard for your sector. Ask in every quote for the calculation of the audit days. Also ask about the deadline for nonconformities. Then you know it before you sign.
Sources
- IAS, summary of ISO/IEC 17021-1:2015 section 9 (process rules) iasonline.org
- IAS, summary of ISO/IEC 17021-1:2015 section 5 (impartiality) cdn-v2.iasonline.org
- ISO/IEC 17021-1:2015, definitions of major and minor nonconformity (3.12, 3.13), via the ERA terminology collection era.europa.eu
- Global ACI-TECH-3-004 (M) version 1.0, Determination of Audit Time (was IAF MD 5:2023) sys.global-aci.org
- Global ACI-TECH-3-003 (M) version 1.0, Use of ICT for Auditing/Assessment Purposes (was IAF MD 4:2025) sys.global-aci.org
- Global ACI, IAF and ILAC Document Cross-Reference Table v14.0 sys.global-aci.org
- RvA, ASR103 accreditation of certification bodies for management systems, version 1.0 rva.nl
- RvA, complaints procedure QA008 (complaints about accredited bodies count as a report) rva.nl